Paper vs. Plastic Packaging: A Guide for Small Businesses

Paper vs. Plastic Packaging: A Guide for Small Businesses

We're sure you've pondered this question at some point: "Paper or plastic?" No, we're not talking about your choice at the grocery checkout, but rather about the packaging options for your small business.

The decision may seem trivial, but it can make a pretty big impact — on your budget, on your customers' perception, and on our lovely planet too. Choosing the right packaging not only drives customer satisfaction but reflects your brand values as well. Not to mention the environmental implications. 

Paper packaging offers eco-friendliness and a premium feel but may face durability challenges and higher costs, while plastic packaging provides durability and cost-effectiveness but raises concerns about its environmental impact and consumer perception. Consider product characteristics, customer values, budget constraints, environmental impacts, local regulations, and brand identity to strike a balance that supports both business growth and sustainability.


In this article, we'll look into the advantages and disadvantages of both paper and plastic packaging to help you make an informed choice. Stick with us to find the best solution for your small business packaging needs. 

Understanding the Basics: Paper and Plastic Packaging

When it comes to packaging, there are two primary players in the game: paper and plastic. Each of them offers distinct advantages and applications.

Paper packaging uses different types of paper-based materials and comes in various forms, like cardboard boxes, Kraft paper bags, and wrapping sheets. Not only that, but it's also pretty versatile. Paper packaging is often used in industries, such as food, retail, and e-commerce; think books, food containers, and even beverage cartons.

Then you've got the sleek and sturdy plastic packaging. This includes your plastic bags, shrink wrap, bubble wrap, and air pillows. It's durable, lightweight, and can protect your goods from the elements, such as moisture and dust.

Plastic packaging is widely used in numerous industries, including food, electronics, healthcare, and more. However, plastic packaging, when not properly managed, can pose significant environmental issues due to its long degradation process and reliance on non-renewable resources for production.

Pros and Cons of Paper Packaging for Small Businesses

In addition to its eco-friendly attributes, paper packaging also offers other benefits, such as tactile appeal, lower minimum order quantities, and positive impact on brand image. However, it is important to be aware of potential durability issues, cost implications, space requirements, and limited barrier properties associated with paper packaging. Let's get into the details.

Pros of Paper Packaging

Environmentally Friendly

Paper packaging is biodegradable and usually made from trees, a renewable resource. This helps you reduce your carbon footprint. In responsibly managed forests, more trees are also planted than cut down, which makes paper a sustainable packaging option.

Paper is also compostable. That means it breaks down into natural components in compost conditions and leaves no harmful residues. 

Furthermore, paper packaging, except for those boxes with plastic lining, can typically be recycled several times over. This contributes to a circular economy where resources are used efficiently, and products are designed to be recycled and reused so that there is less waste.

Premium and Natural Feel

There's a certain rustic charm to paper packaging that plastic just can't match. The texture and natural look of paper can provide a premium feel, enhancing your customers' unboxing experience.

This premium and natural appeal often resonates particularly well with environmentally conscious consumers who appreciate sustainable packaging choices. It aligns with their values and preferences for eco-friendly options, which makes them more likely to choose products that use paper packaging. 

Additionally, the tactile quality of paper can attract consumers who seek a more authentic and tactile connection with the products they purchase. This appeals to those who appreciate craftsmanship and attention to detail. 

Lower Minimum Order Quantity (MOQ)

Paper packaging often comes with a lower minimum order quantity (MOQ) compared to plastic. This means you can order fewer units at a time, which can be a big plus for small businesses. It allows you to manage your inventory more efficiently and reduces the need for large storage space. 

Enhances Brand Image

Paper packaging can give your brand a classic, artisanal feel. If sustainability and a hand-crafted appeal align with your brand values, paper packaging can certainly help you make a statement. 

Cons of Paper Packaging

Potential Durability Issues

While paper packaging can be sturdy enough for many uses, it may not be as tough as plastic. It can be susceptible to tearing and doesn't hold up as well against moisture. However, you can counter these issues through careful design and selection of your paper packaging materials. 

If durability is a major concern, consider factors like material thickness, structural integrity, print quality, and overall durability. Look for sturdy construction and ensure it meets your specific product protection and branding needs.


Typically, paper packaging materials can be more expensive than their plastic counterparts. This could be a significant factor for small businesses, particularly when you're just starting out.

Space Requirements

Paper packaging is often bulkier than plastic, which can potentially complicate your storage arrangements. 

Limited Barrier Properties

One downside of paper packaging is its limited protection against external conditions. Paper has fewer barrier properties compared to plastic, especially when it comes to moisture resistance. This could be a factor if you're shipping products sensitive to water or humidity.

While paper packaging has its pros and cons, its environmental benefits and the potential for a positive impact on your brand image are compelling. But how does it compare with plastic packaging? Let's find out.

Pros and Cons of Plastic Packaging for Small Businesses

Plastic packaging offers numerous advantages, including its longevity, cost-effectiveness, superior barrier properties, lightweight nature, and versatile design options. It provides reliable protection for delicate goods during transit and can be a budget-friendly choice, particularly for large-scale packaging needs. 

On the flip side, plastic packaging is associated with environmental concerns, including its long-lasting environmental impact, dependence on non-renewable resources, and the growing negative perception among consumers. Let’s take a closer look.

Pros of Plastic Packaging

Longevity and Durability

Plastic packaging isn't just tough - it's long-lasting, too. Its resistance to impact, tearing, and environmental conditions makes it an excellent choice for protecting goods, especially delicate ones, during transit. 


Generally, plastic packaging materials tend to be cheaper than paper, which can help small businesses manage expenses effectively. When it comes to large-scale packaging needs, it can be a budget-friendly choice too. With lower material and production costs, plastic packaging can help small businesses keep their expenses in check while scaling operations.

Superior Barrier Properties

Plastic excels in providing a barrier against external conditions, including moisture, dust, and bacteria. If you're shipping products susceptible to such elements, plastic packaging can be a reliable guard.

Lightweight and Space-Efficient

Plastic packaging is usually lighter and takes up less space than paper. This can reduce shipping costs and ease your storage requirements.

Versatile with Multiple Design Options

Whether you need clear plastic bags, colorful containers, or custom-shaped packages, plastic offers a wide range of design options. This versatility can help you create unique unboxing experiences for your customers.

Cons of Plastic Packaging

Environmental Impact

Plastic's environmental impact is probably its biggest downside. It takes hundreds, if not thousands, of years for plastic to break down. And when it does, it doesn't biodegrade — instead, it breaks down into tiny pieces called microplastics, contaminating the ecosystem.

Dependent on Non-Renewable Resources

Plastic is typically made from non-renewable fossil fuels. This dependence on limited resources is another point against plastic from a sustainability perspective. It does not only contribute to resource depletion but also compounds the environmental impact due to the carbon emissions from plastic production.

Growing Negative Perception Among Consumers

As awareness about plastic pollution increases, consumers are increasingly preferring businesses that shun plastic. So, plastic packaging could potentially harm your brand's image.

In summary, although plastic packaging comes with advantages, such as durability and versatility, the environmental concerns it raises can't be ignored. As a small business owner, it's crucial to closely consider these pros and cons in light of your brand values, customer expectations, and practical needs.

Environmental Footprint: A Comparative Analysis

Paper packaging seems to be a clear winner when it comes to eco-friendliness, right? It's biodegradable, recyclable (but not those with plastic lining!), compostable, and comes from renewable sources. But don't get carried away just yet.

One concern with paper packaging is deforestation. The production process involves cutting down trees, which could contribute to deforestation and habitat loss if not managed responsibly. Plus, the process uses a lot of water and energy, and can also release pollutants into the air and water.

Moreover, the carbon footprint of paper packaging is not insignificant. While transporting lighter plastic packaging can lead to less fuel usage and lower carbon emissions, heavier paper packaging can have a greater impact on transportation-related emissions. 

The good news is, the paper industry has made significant strides in reducing its environmental impact. More and more companies use recycled material or source from sustainably managed forests.

On the other hand, plastic packaging, being durable and sometimes recyclable, has its benefits. However, the reality is a bit more complicated.

On the downside, not all types of plastic are recyclable. Plastic's durability means it sticks around for a long time. Plastic that ends up in landfills or our oceans can take hundreds of years to degrade. In the process, it poses a threat to marine life that often mistake plastic waste for food.

As for its carbon footprint, plastic fares better in transportation as it's lighter than paper. However, the production process can be energy-intensive and release harmful emissions. Plastic is made from fossil fuels, a non-renewable resource. The extraction and refining of these resources contribute significantly to greenhouse gas emissions. 

So, when it comes to the environmental impact, neither paper nor plastic is a perfect solution. As a small business, the key is to use resources responsibly — reduce, reuse, recycle — and to educate your customers to do the same. Sustainability is a journey, and every little step counts!

Economic Implications for Small Businesses

With a clear understanding of the environmental impact, let's switch gears and talk about money. Because as much as we'd love to save the world, we need to save our budgets too, right? Below is a comparison of the economic implications of using paper versus plastic packaging for small businesses.

Paper Packaging: Where Costs Add Up

Paper packaging can come with higher initial costs. The production process can be pricier due to the raw materials used and the energy-consuming production methods. Also, because paper packaging is bulkier and heavier than plastic, it can lead to higher storage and shipping costs.

However, it's important to factor in the potential long-term benefits. Quality paper packaging can enhance your brand's image, appeal to eco-conscious consumers, and promote customer loyalty — all of which could translate to increased sales over time.

Investing in paper packaging can also pave the way for premium pricing. Customers who are conscious of sustainability are often willing to pay more for products from businesses that prioritize the environment.

Plastic Packaging: Cheaper, But at What Cost?

Plastic packaging solutions are generally cheaper to produce due to lower material costs and more efficient production processes. They're also more lightweight, which can save you a dime or two on shipping costs.

That said, the hidden costs of plastic should not be overlooked. Regulatory costs are increasing as more jurisdictions impose restrictions on plastic use, such as the plastic bag ban in California. These can add to the total cost of using plastic packaging and eat into your profits. Moreover, the potential damage to your brand image among an increasingly environmentally aware consumer base could lead to longer-term financial impacts.

When making your packaging decision, consider both the immediate and long-term financial implications. The cheapest solution may not be the most cost-effective in the long term, especially when you factor in brand perception and the growing consumer preference for sustainable business practices.

Consumer Perception and Market Trends

With the rise in environmental consciousness, many consumers are voting with their wallets for greener products. They are more likely to return to and advocate for brands that align with their values.

Paper packaging, with its natural, rustic appeal and eco-friendly credentials, has been gaining favor. It sends a strong message about your commitment to sustainability, which can enhance your brand image and appeal to environmentally conscious consumers. It can cement your brand's reputation as a responsible business.

For example, Calvin Klein, a fashion brand, is known for its efforts in adopting sustainable packaging choices. They have made significant strides in reducing their environmental footprint by incorporating recycled materials into their packaging. They use recycled paper and cardboard to create their boxes and other packaging materials, which reduces the demand for virgin materials and minimizes waste.

Moreover, there's a growing trend towards “unboxing experiences.” A well-designed paper package can make the unboxing feel more personal and premium, potentially boosting customer satisfaction and loyalty.

Meanwhile, plastic packaging, with its durability and practicality, has been the go-to choice for many businesses. However, as awareness of plastic pollution grows, consumers are increasingly viewing plastic packaging unfavorably. 

More and more, customers are pushing back against excessive plastic use, and this sentiment is set to strengthen with younger, more environmentally aware generations forming a greater share of the consumer base. 

For this reason, although plastic packaging may meet practical needs, its negative impact on your brand's perception and potential future sales is a necessary consideration. As consumers become more vigilant about sustainability, brands sticking to plastic may find themselves losing customer loyalty and facing reputational challenges.

In the ever-evolving marketplace, it's key to stay up-to-date with consumer perceptions and market trends. This will ensure your packaging choices align with both your brand values and your customers' expectations. Remember, your packaging does not only protect your products; it is also a reflection of your brand's identity.

Recycling Dynamics: What Small Businesses Should Know

Paper is often lauded for its recyclability. Many forms of paper packaging can be recycled, and the fibers can be reused multiple times. Furthermore, paper composts naturally, which means even unrecycled paper packaging won't linger in the environment for centuries.

Paper recycling starts with collection and sorting, after which the paper is broken down into pulp using water and chemicals. The pulp is then cleaned, de-inked, and processed into new paper products. 

While paper can be recycled multiple times, the fibers do shorten with each cycle, eventually reaching a point where they can't be used anymore. Another challenge with paper recycling occurs when the paper is combined with other materials (like plastic coatings), which can make it more difficult, if not impossible, to recycle. 

On the other hand, plastic recycling begins with sorting plastics by type. The sorted plastic is cleaned, shredded into small flakes, and then melted down. These melted plastic pellets can then be molded into new products. 

However, not all types of plastic are recyclable, and the recycling rates for plastic are generally low. In 2021, the U.S. managed to recycle just about 6% of the massive 51 million tons of plastic waste it generated, according to data from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. Moreover, each recycling cycle degrades the quality of plastic, which limits its recyclability.

One of the biggest challenges with plastic recycling is its longevity. Unlike paper, plastic does not decompress in standard composting environments, meaning it can hang around for hundreds of years if not recycled. 

Nowadays, advancements in biodegradable plastics and plastic recycling technologies present opportunities for more sustainable plastic use and disposal. However, the debate over plastics and their alternatives, as well as their environmental impact, continues. Even the most eco-friendly bioplastics have limitations. 

As a small business, considering these recycling dynamics is important when choosing your packaging. Opting for easily recyclable or compostable packaging can reduce your environmental impact and appeal to eco-conscious consumers. To enhance your brand's commitment to sustainability and create a deeper connection with your customers, consider educating yourself and your customers about proper recycling.

Making the Right Choice: Key Considerations for Small Businesses

Choosing between paper and plastic packaging depends on a variety of factors that are unique to your business. This includes your product type and specific needs, your target audience, budget, as well as environmental and legal considerations. Finding the sweet spot among these factors will ensure that your packaging supports both your business growth and your commitment to sustainability.

Check out these considerations below that can guide your decision.

  • Know Your Products: Consider the nature of your products. Are they heavy or light? Fragile or sturdy? Do they need protection from moisture? The physical features of your products can influence whether paper or plastic packaging would be more suitable.
  • Understand Your Audience: Consider understanding your customers' values and preferences. If your audience is environmentally conscious, they may appreciate and support your choice of eco-friendly paper packaging.
  • Assess Your Budget: Consider both immediate and longer-term costs when choosing your packaging. While plastic might seem cheaper upfront, paper could offer long-term returns through an enhanced brand image and customer loyalty.
  • Weigh Environmental Impacts: Evaluate the environmental implications of your packaging choice. This includes considering recyclability, the lifespan of the material, and the production process's environmental footprint. 
  • Consider Legalities and Regulations: Keep an eye on local laws and regulations regarding packaging materials. Some regions, such as in California, are implementing strict regulations on plastic, which could influence your packaging decision.
  • Reflect on Your Brand Identity: Your packaging is an extension of your brand. It should reflect your brand's identity and values. If your brand promises sustainability and environmental care, your packaging should align with that message.

Wrapping Up: The Path Forward for Packaging

Paper or plastic? It's a question that demands thoughtful deliberation, considering the variety of factors at play, from budget constraints and product needs to customer expectations and environmental impacts. Particularly in a world that's growing more environmentally conscious, your packaging decisions can significantly influence how your brand is perceived.

But the good news is that informed decision-making is absolutely possible. And you're not alone in this journey. You can reach out to experts, connect with other businesses, and most importantly, listen to your customers.

Also, remember that packaging isn't a one-and-done decision. As technology evolves, new packaging materials and methods will emerge. Likewise, consumer preferences and regulations will shift over time. So, periodically re-evaluating your packaging decisions is not just beneficial — it's essential.

At the end of the day, the goal is to embrace packaging choices that support your operational needs, resonate with your brand values, and reflect a strong commitment to our planet. So, as you press forward on your business journey, keep these guiding principles in mind. After all, small businesses like yours are key to shaping a sustainable, eco-conscious future. Keep leading the way!

Ready to transform your packaging game? Meet our ABC Box line at Impack. These thin, sleek boxes are designed to slip right through letter mail slots and help you save on postage costs. They looks stunning, needing no extra effort to stand out like ordinary boxes often do. 

With our ABC Boxes, you can save time on packing orders, reduce the need for additional packing accessories, and still deliver your products in a gift-ready package.

Let our ABC Boxes revolutionize the way you pack and ship your products. Let's create a win-win for you and your customers, all while making a sustainable choice. 

Back to blog

Leave a comment