Skip to content
Mailer Bags vs Shipping Boxes: Which is Best for Your Business?

Mailer Bags vs Shipping Boxes: Which is Best for Your Business?

When it comes to running your online shop, we know that every detail counts. From the moment a customer clicks 'buy', their experience with your brand is only just beginning. One major component? The packaging. 

It's like the first handshake, the first impression, that either makes or breaks the unboxing experience. And with so many packaging options out there – it can be a tad overwhelming. Right?

When selecting the perfect packaging solution for your e-commerce business, the debate often boils down to mailer bags versus shipping boxes. Each has its own set of advantages and potential drawbacks, and the right choice depends on various factors including your product type, budget, and branding strategy. 

In this guide, we break down the differences between mailer boxes and shipping boxes to help you make an informed decision.

Understanding Mailer Bags

Mailer bags are lightweight, flexible envelopes designed to protect and secure your goods for shipping. Think of them as the eco-friendly cousin of the traditional bubble mailers but without the excessive plastic. 

Here's why a lot of small businesses are switching to these green champs:

  • Lighter and Cheaper: Mailer bags weigh less, which means cheaper shipping costs. Plus, they require less material to produce, making them a more cost-effective option. 
  • Eco-friendly: These guys are usually compostable, biodegradable, or recyclable. They are a fantastic way to reduce your shop's carbon footprint.
  • Space-savers: They take up less storage space compared to boxes. Every square inch counts when you're a small shop, and mailer bags can help you maximize your space!
  • Versatile: Mailer bags come in various sizes and can be custom-printed with your branding.

But let's step back for a moment. Mailer bags are great, but they aren't perfect for everything:

  • Less Protection: Mailer bags might not provide enough protection for fragile or sharp items. If your products need some extra cushioning, this could be a sticking point.
  • Potential for Damage: While mailer bags are generally durable, they can sometimes get torn or punctured during shipping.

So when should you use mailer bags? They're perfect for clothing items, textiles, or non-breakable items. If your business primarily deals with these types of products, then mailer bags could be a real game-changer for you.

Mailer bags can be a solid choice for businesses prioritizing eco-friendliness and cost-effectiveness, but don’t forget that, it all depends on what you're shipping. It's all about finding the right packaging that matches your product and brand values.

Understanding Shipping Boxes

Shipping boxes are your traditional packaging heroes. Available in various sizes and strengths, these boxes are designed to keep your products safe and secure during transit.

Some reasons why businesses love shipping boxes are as follows:

  • Enhanced Protection: Boxes typically offer more protection for your products, especially if they're fragile or high-value. Bubble wrap, packing peanuts — you can use them all in a box!
  • Customizable Sizes: From small, flat boxes to larger, cubic ones, there's a shipping box for nearly every product.
  • Branding Opportunities: With more surface area comes more branding opportunities. Boxes offer plenty of space for your logo, social media handles, or any branding elements that can wow your customers.
  • Unboxing Experience: Shipping boxes can provide an elevated unboxing experience that customers love and share on social media.

But as with everything, shipping boxes also have their downsides:

  • Higher Costs: Shipping boxes can be more expensive due to their weight and size. And then there are the costs for additional padding materials.
  • More Waste: Unless recycled, boxes can contribute to more waste compared to mailer bags.
  • Not Ideal for Smaller, Non-Fragile Items: Shipping a small, robust item in a big box? That might be overkill.

So, when does it make sense to choose shipping boxes? They are ideal when you're shipping fragile, larger, or high-value items. They're also a great choice when you want to create a memorable unboxing experience for your customers.

Shipping boxes may cost a little more, but for certain products and for enhancing that special unboxing moment, they're worth every penny.

Table 1: Comparison of the Pros, Cons, and Best Uses of Mailer Bags and Shipping Boxes

Mailer Bags

Shipping Boxes


  • Eco-friendly
  • Space-saving
  • Lightweight and cheaper
  • Versatile and customizable
  • Customizable sizes
  • Enhanced protection
  • More branding opportunities 
  • Premium unboxing experience


  • Less protection for fragile items Potential for damage during shipping
  • Higher costs (size, weight, padding) Can contribute to more waste
  • Not ideal for smaller, non-fragile items

Best For

  • Textiles
  • Clothing
  • Non-breakable items
  • Fragile
  • Larger, high-value items
  • When you want a premium unboxing experience

Factors to Consider

Choosing between mailer bags and shipping boxes isn't a coin toss. It's a strategic decision that takes into consideration several key aspects of your business. Here are some factors to bear in mind while making your choice:

  • The Nature of Your Product: Are you shipping hand-knit scarves or hand-painted ceramics? The type, size, weight, and fragility of your products play a crucial role in choosing your packaging. 
  • Shipping Costs: Every ounce and inch counts when calculating shipping costs. Going lightweight with mailer bags could save you some bucks, while larger, heavier boxes could increase your expenses. 
  • Sustainability: Show your customers you care about the planet! Going for compostable mailer bags or recyclable boxes can go a long way in boosting your green credentials. 
  • Branding and Unboxing Experience: Packaging isn't just about protection – it's part of your brand story. It's the first physical touchpoint a customer has with your brand. A memorable unboxing experience can build customer loyalty, and the packaging you choose plays a significant role in that.
  • Storage Space: If you're running a small shop, every inch of space is precious. Mailer bags often require less storage space compared to boxes, which could be a deciding factor.

Coming to a final decision requires considering these factors and finding the sweet spot that fits your product type, shipping costs, brand goals, and commitment to sustainability. Remember, be it a mailer bag or a shipping box, the packaging you choose represents your brand in the hands of your customer. Make it count! 

The Impact on Branding

Your packaging isn't just a vessel to get your products from point A to B. It's a powerful tool to represent your brand and to create a lasting first impression. 

Being the first physical contact a customer has with your brand, how your packaging looks, feels, and performs can either make or break their experience. It's not just about the aesthetics, it's also about how well it protects the products inside, how easy it is to open, and how it can be disposed of. Simply put, your packaging is a silent brand ambassador.

We love a good mailer bag. They're sleek, minimal, and ideal for a brand that wants to communicate its commitment to sustainability. Plus, mailer bags can be custom-printed with your brand colors, logo, or even a personalized message. While they may not offer the grand unboxing experience like a box, they sure do signal that your brand cares about the environment.

Now, if your brand leans more towards creating a "wow" factor, shipping boxes could be your go-to. The extra space on boxes allows for larger logos, more information about your company, and other branding elements. It's not about being flashy – it's about creating an unforgettable unboxing experience. 

And then there are the cherries on top – the little things that can make a big difference. Accents like customized tapes, stickers, or personalized notes can add a unique touch to both mailer bags and boxes. These small elements can enhance the connection between your brand and your customers, making them feel special.

While both mailer bags and shipping boxes can represent your brand's identity and values, the choice between the two ultimately hinges on your specific branding goals and the experience you want to provide to your customers. 

Making the Final Decision

Now, we’re done unpacking (pun intended) quite a lot about mailer bags and shipping boxes. But how do you choose the right one for your brand? 

Start off by considering all the factors we've touched upon. The nature of your product, shipping costs, sustainability goals, branding, and storage space – it's a balancing act of all these elements that will guide your final decision.

We know it sounds a bit cliché, but it's true. There's no one-size-fits-all answer. Your business is unique, and so are your packaging needs. What works for one brand may not work for another. So, take your time to assess all aspects.

Next, test the waters. Try out both mailer bags and boxes, monitor customer feedback, and see what works best for your brand and your customers. Your customers' perspective can be an invaluable tool in deciding.

If sustainability is a cornerstone of your brand, lean into packaging options that align with this. An eco-friendly approach not only helps our planet but also resonates with customers who share these values. 

Ultimately, take note of this – the right packaging solution enhances the customer experience, helps solidify your brand in the customer's mind, and can contribute to preserving our environment. It's a win-win for your brand, your customers, and our planet. Happy packing!

For more business tips and tricks, click here.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published..

Cart 0

Your cart is currently empty.

Start Shopping
RuffRuff App RuffRuff App by Tsun